When Scoring Becomes a Process, Not a Formula

One of the biggest challenges in puzzle design is explaining scoring without overwhelming the player.

At some point, every system runs into the same risk:

It starts to feel like math.

Count structures.
Apply rules.
Multiply values.

Even if the underlying logic is elegant, the experience can feel heavy.

That was the danger in Crowns & Towns.


THE ORIGINAL PROBLEM

Early versions of the scoring system leaned toward explanation.

To fully understand how points were calculated, a player needed to grasp:

How structures depended on each other
How support chains worked
How values were applied

Individually, none of this was complicated.
But taken together, it created friction.

Players weren’t just playing.
They were trying to understand a system before they could use it.


THE SHIFT THAT CHANGED EVERYTHING

The breakthrough came by reframing scoring entirely.

Instead of presenting it as a formula, it became a process:

Build
Support
Record
Score

This did something subtle but powerful.

It removed the need to understand everything upfront.

Players didn’t need to know how the system worked in full.
They only needed to follow the next step.


WHY PROCESS WORKS BETTER

This approach aligns with how people naturally learn.

We don’t start with full comprehension.
We start with action.

Do something.
See what happens.
Adjust.

Meaning comes after.

By structuring scoring as a sequence of actions, the game allows understanding to emerge naturally through play.

Players are guided without being overwhelmed.


FROM RULES TO FLOW

When scoring becomes a process, something important happens.

The player stops thinking in terms of rules.

They begin to experience flow.

Instead of asking:

“How do I calculate this?”

They begin to think:

“What’s my next step?”

That shift reduces cognitive load and keeps the player engaged.


A SYSTEM THAT TEACHES ITSELF

The result is a system that doesn’t need to explain itself all at once.

It reveals itself gradually.

Each step builds on the previous one:

Build something
See how it is supported
Record what qualifies
Score the result

Over time, players begin to understand the deeper logic without ever being forced to study it.


THE CORE INSIGHT

The lesson extends beyond this game.

Players don’t need to understand a system in order to use it.

They need to use the system in order to understand it.

In Crowns & Towns, scoring is not something you solve before playing.

It’s something you learn by doing.

And that difference is what makes the experience feel intuitive, approachable, and surprisingly deep.

Scroll to Top